The definition of assault in Section 378 of the Penal Law is far broader than people tend to think.
What is assault under the law?
The definition of assault in Section 378 of the Penal Law is far broader than people tend to think. Assault is striking, applying force, or pushing a person in any manner, direct or indirect, without his free consent. The definition also includes the application of heat, cold, electricity, gas, or light in a way that creates discomfort to the victim. The rationale: any intentional creation of an unpleasant situation for another person may constitute assault.
The punishment for basic assault under Section 379 is up to two years of imprisonment.
The element of consent, when does it negate the offense?
The victim’s consent changes the legal picture. Express consent is the clearest, but implied consent from the victim’s conduct may also suffice, provided that it corresponds to the degree of force used. The stronger the force and the more serious the potential harm, the stricter the court is in the evidentiary requirement for consent. Consent obtained by fraud, regarding the identity of the person applying the force, the nature of the force, or false inducements, is not legitimate consent under the law.
The aggravating circumstances, what doubles the punishment?
Section 382 of the law establishes three aggravating circumstances, each of which doubles the maximum punishment:
Multiple assailants (Section 382(a)) , when two or more assailants joined together in the assault, or additional persons were present there during the act. The rationale is twofold: more serious harm to the victim and the moral wrong in a group assault. The punishment: up to 4 years of imprisonment for each of the assailants.
Assault of a spouse, family member, minor, or helpless person (Section 382(b)) , the breach of trust and the close relationship aggravate the offense. The law also applies to former spouses and former family members , expressly covering disputes after separation. The punishment for simple assault of a spouse: up to 4 years of imprisonment.
Assault of a spouse that caused actual bodily harm , assault causing actual bodily harm is a separate offense under Section 380, punishable by 3 years. When the victim is a spouse, the punishment is doubled, up to 6 years of imprisonment.
Multiple aggravating circumstances in one case
There may be cases in which several aggravating circumstances exist simultaneously, for example a group assault of a spouse that caused injury. Multiple aggravating circumstances will affect the sentencing range set by the court, even if they do not always lead to the maximum punishment under each section.
Possible defenses
Common defenses in aggravated assault cases: the victim’s consent; self-defense; denial of the assault itself; denial of the aggravating circumstance (for example, a claim that the victim does not meet the definition of a "spouse" under the law); or a claim that the force used does not reach the threshold of "assault" under the statutory definition. Each of these claims requires precise factual and legal analysis, and they should be formulated before the questioning, not during it.
Legal representation in aggravated assault cases
Israel Arama, former member of the Tel Aviv District Attorney's Office, accompanies suspects and defendants in assault offenses of all classifications, from the initial investigation, through formulating the line of defense, the hearing, and up to conducting the proceeding in court. The correct distinction between an aggravating circumstance and a circumstance that is not aggravating can change the relevant sentencing framework by many years. Contact us for an initial consultation without obligation.
What is assault under the law?
The definition of assault in section 378 of the Penal Law is far broader than people tend to think. Assault is striking, applying force, or pushing a person in any way, directly or indirectly, without their free consent. The definition also includes the application of heat, cold, electricity, gas, or light in a manner that creates discomfort for the victim. The rationale: any intentional creation of an unpleasant condition for another may constitute assault. The penalty for basic assault under section 379 is up to two years of imprisonment.
The element of consent, when does it negate the offense?
The victim’s consent changes the legal picture. Express consent is the clearest, but implied consent from the victim’s conduct may also suffice, provided that it corresponds to the degree of force used. The stronger the force and the more serious the potential harm, the stricter the court is in the evidentiary requirement for consent. Consent obtained by fraud, regarding the identity of the person applying the force, the nature of the force, or false inducements, is not legitimate consent under the law.
Multiple aggravating circumstances in one case — what is important to know?
There may be cases in which several aggravating circumstances exist simultaneously, for example a group assault of a spouse that caused injury. Multiple aggravating circumstances will affect the sentencing range set by the court, even if they do not always lead to the maximum punishment under each section.
Possible defenses — what is important to know?
Common defenses in aggravated assault cases: the victim’s consent; self-defense; denial of the assault itself; denial of the aggravating circumstance (for example, a claim that the victim does not meet the definition of a "spouse" under the law); or a claim that the force used does not reach the threshold of "assault" under the statutory definition. Each of these claims requires precise factual and legal analysis, and they should be formulated before the questioning, not during it.
This information is for initial orientation about the service and contact process. It is not individual legal advice.
Initial call No obligation